
Because apparently, choosing what to have for dinner requires a full investigation.
You made a decision.
Excellent.
You considered your options, weighed up the possibilities and finally chose what seemed right.
So naturally, five minutes later, you’re questioning the entire thing.
“What if I made the wrong choice?”
“Should I have gone with the other option?”
“What if this turns out badly?”
Before you know it, you’ve reopened the investigation, interviewed three imaginary witnesses and appointed yourself chairperson of the What-If Committee.
All because you decided to buy the blue dress instead of the green one.
Why do I second-guess every decision I make?
And when did trusting your own judgement become harder than assembling flat-pack furniture without instructions?
Let’s investigate.
When Every Decision Becomes a Major Production
Some decisions deserve careful consideration.
Changing careers.
Buying a house.
Making important financial commitments.
Choosing whether to tell your hairdresser you’re not particularly thrilled about your new fringe.
That last one requires extraordinary courage.
But what happens when even the smallest decisions leave you questioning yourself?
Perhaps you recognise some of these habits:
- You spend ages researching options before making a choice.
- You ask several people for their opinions, then feel more confused.
- You replay conversations, wondering whether you said the wrong thing.
- You make a decision but continue comparing alternatives.
- You worry about disappointing people with your choices.
- You struggle to move forward unless you’re absolutely certain.
Sound familiar?
Congratulations.
Your brain has established an entire Department of Decision Analysis.
Unfortunately, nobody has informed the department that most decisions don’t require a parliamentary inquiry.
Why Do I Second-Guess Every Decision I Make?
Here’s something worth considering.
What if second-guessing yourself isn’t really about making better decisions?
What if it’s about trying to avoid the uncomfortable feelings that might come with getting something wrong?
Perhaps you’re afraid of making a mistake.
Maybe you worry about criticism.
Or perhaps you believe that choosing incorrectly means you’ve failed in some way.
So you analyse.
You compare.
You seek reassurance.
And you keep searching for the one piece of information that will finally make you feel certain.
But there’s a problem.
Not every decision comes with a guarantee.
Sometimes, you can make a thoughtful choice and still discover that another option might have worked better.
That doesn’t mean you’re incapable.
It means you made a decision using the information available to you at the time.
Which, incidentally, is how most human decisions work.
Rather inconvenient, I know.
The Hidden Belief Behind Constant Second-Guessing
Our beliefs about making mistakes can develop through our experiences.
Perhaps you grew up in an environment where getting things wrong attracted criticism.
Maybe your decisions were frequently questioned.
Or perhaps you learned that making mistakes meant disappointing someone whose approval mattered to you.
Over time, you may have developed a belief that sounds something like this:
“I can’t trust myself to make the right decisions.”
Or perhaps:
“If I make the wrong choice, it means I’m not good enough.”
Now imagine carrying those beliefs into adulthood.
Every decision becomes more than a choice.
It becomes a test.
A test of your intelligence.
Your judgement.
Your competence.
Even your worth.
No wonder deciding what to do feels exhausting.
You’re not simply choosing between options.
You’re trying to avoid failing an imaginary examination.
And the examiner?
Well, unfortunately, she’s living rent-free inside your head.
Why Asking Everyone Else Doesn’t Always Help
Let’s say you’re considering buying a new outfit.
You like it.
It suits you.
You feel good wearing it.
Wonderful.
But then you start wondering.
“Is it really flattering?”
“Am I too old for this?”
“What if everyone thinks it looks ridiculous?”
So you ask someone else.
They love it.
Excellent.
But wait.
What if they’re just being nice?
Better ask another person.
They suggest a different colour.
Interesting.
Now you’re reconsidering the entire purchase.
Three opinions later, you’ve somehow managed to become less confident than when you started.
Here’s the thing.
Other people’s opinions can provide useful information, but they can’t replace your own judgement.
Of course, it makes sense to seek advice when a decision requires expertise or affects other people.
But constantly asking for reassurance about ordinary personal choices can become a habit that reinforces your uncertainty.
Every time you automatically hand the decision to someone else, you miss an opportunity to practise trusting yourself.
And self-trust develops through experience.
Not through obtaining unanimous approval from a committee.
The Problem With Trying to Make the Perfect Decision
Ah, perfectionism.
That delightful belief that there’s one correct answer and your job is to find it.
Preferably without making any mistakes along the way.
But here’s a question.
What if several different choices could work out perfectly well?
Imagine you’re choosing between two restaurants.
Both have good reviews.
Both serve food you enjoy.
Both are within your budget.
Yet you spend an hour comparing menus because you don’t want to pick the wrong one.
What would actually happen if you chose the restaurant that turned out to be slightly less enjoyable?
You’d eat dinner.
You might think, “That was okay, but I’ll try the other place next time.”
And life would continue.
No international incident.
No formal inquiry.
No permanent damage to your reputation as a competent adult.
Sometimes, we give everyday decisions far more emotional significance than they deserve.
Because somewhere beneath the surface, we’re treating an imperfect choice as evidence of personal inadequacy.
But a disappointing outcome isn’t proof that you’re a disappointing person.
When Overthinking Makes You Trust Yourself Even Less
There’s another interesting aspect of second-guessing.
The more you question your decisions, the less confident you may feel about making them.
Imagine making a choice and immediately telling yourself:
“I probably got that wrong.”
Then you analyse everything that could go wrong.
You imagine possible consequences.
You search for information that might confirm your fears.
And eventually, the decision starts feeling dangerous.
Even if it was relatively straightforward.
You may then conclude:
“See? I can’t trust myself. I always get confused.”
But what if the confusion isn’t evidence that you lack judgement?
What if it’s partly the result of repeatedly questioning the judgement you already used?
That’s worth considering.
Because constantly scrutinising your decisions can make even reasonable choices feel uncertain.
Self-Trust Isn’t About Always Being Right
Let’s clear something up.
Confident women make mistakes.
Successful women make mistakes.
Highly intelligent women make mistakes.
Even women who appear to have their lives beautifully organised occasionally make decisions that leave them wondering what on earth they were thinking.
The difference isn’t necessarily that they make fewer mistakes.
Sometimes, it’s that they don’t interpret every mistake as a reflection of their value.
Instead of thinking:
“I got that wrong. I’m hopeless.”
They might think:
“Well, that didn’t work. What can I learn from it?”
See the difference?
One response attacks your identity.
The other acknowledges an experience.
Self-trust isn’t believing you’ll always make the right decision.
It’s believing you can learn, adapt and respond when things don’t go as planned.
And that means you don’t need absolute certainty before making every choice.
How to Stop Second-Guessing Yourself
You don’t need to turn into someone who makes every decision in three seconds.
Thoughtfulness can be a wonderful quality.
The goal is to stop allowing unnecessary doubt to undermine your confidence.
Here are five ways to begin.
1. Separate important decisions from everyday choices
Not every decision deserves the same amount of attention.
Some choices have significant consequences and genuinely require research, discussion or professional advice.
Others?
Well, choosing between two perfectly acceptable lunch options probably doesn’t need a risk assessment.
Before making a decision, ask yourself:
“How much does this decision actually matter?”
If the consequences are minor and easily reversible, give yourself permission to choose without extensive analysis.
Save your mental energy for decisions that deserve it.
2. Notice when you’re seeking reassurance
The next time you feel compelled to ask someone else’s opinion, pause.
Ask yourself:
“Do I genuinely need more information, or am I looking for someone to make me feel certain?”
There’s nothing wrong with getting advice.
But if you already know what you want and you’re simply hoping someone will confirm it, consider trusting your preference.
Start with small decisions.
You don’t need to consult the entire family before choosing what you’d like for lunch.
Unless, of course, you’re paying for everyone.
In which case, some negotiations may be unavoidable.
3. Stop reopening decisions without new information
Have you ever made a decision, felt comfortable with it, then started questioning it again for absolutely no reason?
Try introducing a simple rule.
Once I’ve made a reasonable decision, I won’t reopen it unless something important changes.
That doesn’t mean you can never change your mind.
Of course you can.
But there’s a difference between reconsidering because you’ve learned something new and reconsidering because your inner critic has scheduled another emergency meeting.
Not every thought deserves a fresh investigation.
4. Practise making small decisions independently
Self-trust grows when you give yourself opportunities to use it.
Choose one small decision each day and make it without asking anyone else’s opinion.
Perhaps you decide:
- What to wear.
- Which book to read next.
- What to order for lunch.
- How to spend a free afternoon.
- Which activity you’d genuinely enjoy.
Make the choice.
Then allow yourself to experience the outcome.
If you enjoy it, wonderful.
If you don’t, you’ve learned something.
Either way, you’ve practised making a decision and living with it.
That’s valuable.
5. Change the belief behind your indecision
This is where the deeper transformation begins.
If you’ve spent years believing you can’t trust your judgement, simply telling yourself to “stop overthinking” probably won’t solve the problem.
That’s a bit like telling someone who’s lost their car keys to “just remember where you put them.”
Very helpful. Thank you.
Instead, explore the belief that’s driving the behaviour.
Ask yourself:
“What do I believe it says about me if I make the wrong decision?”
Perhaps your answer is:
“It means I’m not intelligent enough.”
“It means I can’t trust myself.”
“It means people will think I’m incompetent.”
Now question that belief.
Is it actually true?
Or is it an interpretation you’ve become accustomed to making?
Try introducing a different perspective:
“I can trust myself to make thoughtful decisions, even when I can’t predict every outcome.”
You don’t need to believe it perfectly straight away.
Start practising it through your choices.
Your Next Decision Doesn’t Need to Be Perfect
Imagine how much mental energy you could reclaim if you stopped questioning every decision.
You could choose what you want without repeatedly seeking approval.
Make plans without imagining every possible disaster.
And move forward without needing a guarantee that everything will work out exactly as expected.
You’d still consider important information.
Still make thoughtful decisions.
And still occasionally get things wrong.
Because you’re human.
But you wouldn’t automatically treat an imperfect outcome as proof that something is wrong with you.
Your value doesn’t rise or fall with the quality of your decisions.
You are worthy when you choose well.
You are worthy when you change your mind.
And you are still worthy when you order something disappointing for dinner.
Although you may feel mildly betrayed by the menu.
So the next time you catch yourself second-guessing a perfectly reasonable decision, consider asking:
“What would I choose if I trusted myself?”
Then give yourself permission to act on the answer.
No committee meeting required.
What’s Your Self-Worth Personality? 🦋
Constantly second-guessing yourself is just one way your self-worth can influence your everyday choices.
Perhaps you struggle to trust your judgement.
Maybe you find yourself seeking approval, constantly trying to achieve more or putting everyone else’s needs ahead of your own.
Or perhaps you’ve developed the habit of doing everything yourself because asking for help feels uncomfortable.
Different patterns.
But they can all affect how you recognise and appreciate your own value.
Curious which self-worth pattern might be influencing your decisions?
Take the Self-Worth Personality Quiz and discover your dominant pattern, what might be driving it, and one simple shift you can start making today.
Because trusting yourself doesn’t mean having all the answers.
Sometimes, it simply means believing you’re capable of figuring things out.
Even if you occasionally order the wrong pizza.

Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.